When using props, try to integrate the prop into the photo. In other words it must add to the photo not detract. If this is a trophy she's won, then design a pose that is more real to life. Is she proudly showing the trophy? If so, then have her give it more prominence. Also the leaning pose doesn't work very well as she looks off balance. For fitness competitors, work on a shot with more shadows to define the muscle tone.
cheers,
rfs